If you are looking to start a new company, understanding the differences between a company director and a sole trader is crucial.

These two roles come with distinct responsibilities, benefits, and challenges, all of which can impact your financial decisions. In this article, we go into the specifics of each role, helping you to make an informed choice about your future.

What is a Company Director?

A company director is an individual appointed to manage and direct a limited company’s affairs. They are legally responsible for running the company, making strategic decisions, managing operations, and ensuring compliance with necessary legal regulations.

A limited company, also known as a company limited by shares, has its own separate legal entity from its owners (shareholders) and has limited liability. This means that the personal assets of the shareholders are protected from the company’s debts or losses. Even if there is only one shareholder, the company is still an entirely separate entity from the owner.

Limited companies must be registered on Companies House, along with the details of at least one director. This information is then shared on the public register by law.

What is a Sole Trader?

On the other hand, a sole trader runs their own business as a self-employed individual. They may work alone or choose to employ people to work for them.
Unlike a company director, a sole trader does not have a separate legal entity and is therefore personally responsible for the company’s financial liabilities and debts. A sole trader will receive all of the business’s profits and is not subject to the same level of legal and regulatory requirements as a company director.

Setting Up as a Company Director

As a company director, you will need to register your business with Companies House and appoint yourself as a company director. During this process, you must also choose a unique business name that complies with the rules and restrictions set by Companies House.

You’ll need to complete the required forms, either online or through a company formation agency. This agency will take care of the paperwork and submit it to Companies House on your behalf – a process that can take as little as a few hours.

Setting Up as a Sole Trader

Getting started as a sole trader is a completely different process from setting up as a limited company. You are not required to register with Companies House – instead, you’ll need to register yourself as self-employed with HMRC, which you can do using the Government’s online portal. To do this, you’ll just need a few details including:

Your National Insurance number
Your name and home address
Your personal contact details
The name and address of your business (which can be your own name and home address, unless your business has a separate trading address or unique name)
The date you started trading
Details of what your business does

Once you have completed your online registration, you’ll receive a letter from HMRC, usually within a few days, containing details of your responsibilities and obligations as a sole trader.

Administrative Responsibilities of a Company Director

As a company director, your role will involve a range of ongoing administrative duties. You’ll need to ensure Companies House is kept informed of any changes in your or your company’s circumstances and that all information is sent on time. This will include:

The confirmation statement
The annual accounts
Allotment of company shares
Registration of charges
Any changes in your company’s people with significant control (PSC) details
Any changes in your company officers or their details

Administrative Responsibilities of a Sole Trader

As a sole trader, your only legal administrative responsibility will be your annual Self Assessment tax return. You must register for Self Assessment no later than the 5 October following the end of the tax year in which your profits first arose.

If your earnings exceed the VAT threshold (£85,000 or more), you’ll also need to register for VAT. This is a crucial step in ensuring your business is compliant with UK tax laws.

Tax Obligations of a Company Director

As director of a limited company, you will need to pay Corporation Tax on all profits you make as a business. The amount of Corporation Tax you’ll pay will be based on your company’s net income, which is calculated by subtracting your expenses from the business’s revenue.

Here are the steps you need to follow:

Register for Corporation Tax as soon as you start doing business
Keep accounting records and prepare for a Company Tax Return to work out how much tax you owe
Pay Corporation Tax or report if you have nothing to pay by the deadline (usually 9 months and 1 day after the end of your accounting period)
File your Company Tax Return by the deadline (usually 12 months after the end of your accounting period)

Many company directors choose to call on the support of an accountant to assist them in ensuring these obligations are met, as it can otherwise be quite a time-consuming process.

Tax Obligations of a Sole Trader

As a sole trader, you are required to pay Income Tax on all the profits you make above the Personal Allowance of £12,570 (2023/24), along with making National Insurance contributions. You’ll need to register for Self Assessment and file an annual tax return, which can be done online through GOV.UK.

You’ll also need to keep records of your income and any expenses throughout the year, such as bank statements and receipts, so that you are able to accurately fill in your return. You are entitled to claim expenses like office supplies, fuel, and marketing costs, including website hosting and maintenance.

HMRC will then calculate what you owe based on what you have reported in your return.

Income of a Company Director

A company director will usually take a monthly PAYE salary, as well as dividends; a portion of the company’s profits distributed to its shareholders. Dividends are subject to income tax, but there is a small tax-free annual allowance.

The salary and dividends a company director receives will all depend on the profitability of the business; however, generally speaking, a company director’s salary is likely to be much more effective than that of a sole trader.

Income of a Sole Trader

The income of a sole trader will depend on their profits, which, as with any business structure, may vary widely depending on the industry, the level of competition, and the demand for your product or services.

While it is possible for a sole trader to earn just as much income as a company director, it’s often the case that earnings will be comparatively lower, since sole traders do not benefit from dividends and arguably are exposed to greater fluctuations in business.

Pros and Cons

Pros of Being a Company Director

Limited liability protection: Your company is a separate legal entity, which means that your personal assets are protected in case of business debts or legal action against the company.
Access to funding: Limited companies usually find it easier to raise capital through investments, a wider selection of loans, government grants, or issuing shares.
Brand recognition: Limited companies are often perceived as bigger, and therefore have greater credibility, and are given more trust in the market than sole traders.
Opportunities for growth: A company can expand more easily than a sole trader by hiring employees, forming partnerships, securing funding, or acquiring other businesses.
Tax benefits: Company directors are eligible for more tax reliefs, deductions, and lower tax rates than sole traders.

Cons of Being a Company Director

Less control: Company directors often have to share control and decision-making power with other stakeholders, such as shareholders or a board of directors.
Increased accountability: Company directors have more legal and financial responsibilities, such as complying with regulations, preparing financial reports, and managing employees – which can be time-consuming and costly.
Higher costs: Companies may have higher costs associated with incorporation, ongoing legal and accounting fees, and other administrative expenses.
Less privacy: Companies must disclose certain information, such as financial reports and ownership structure, to the public.

Pros of Being a Sole Trader

Greater control: Sole traders have complete control over their business, from decision-making to operations.
Simpler administration: There are fewer legal and regulatory requirements, which can make it easier to start and run a business.
More privacy: Sole traders have greater privacy as they are not required to disclose information about their business or finances to the public.
Lower costs: Sole traders generally have a lower start-up and operational costs compared to companies.
Greater flexibility: They can make changes to their business quickly and easily, without needing to consult with other stakeholders.

Cons of Being a Sole Trader

Unlimited personal liability: Sole traders are personally responsible for the debts and legal liabilities of their business, which could mean that personal assets may be at risk in the event of financial or legal trouble.
Limited access to funding: Sole traders may find it harder to access financing and investment opportunities compared to limited companies.
More difficult to build recognition: Establishing brand recognition and credibility may be more challenging as a sole trader.
Limited growth opportunities: Sole traders may find it difficult to scale their business beyond their own capacity, due to restricted resources and limited funding.
Higher tax rates: Sole traders are often subject to higher tax rates and fewer tax deductions compared to limited companies.

Understanding the differences between a company director and a sole trader is essential when structuring a new venture.

Each role comes with its own set of unique responsibilities, benefits, and challenges. As a company director, you’ll have more administrative duties but also more protection from personal liability. As a sole trader, you’ll have fewer formal responsibilities but also more personal risk.

Choosing between the two roles depends on your personal circumstances, your business goals, and your risk tolerance. It’s important to weigh the pros and cons carefully and consider seeking professional advice if you’re unsure.

Introducing 1st Formations Ltd.

1st Formations is the UK’s leading company formation agent.

Founded in 2014, they have formed over 1 million companies and assisted many thousands of clients to grow their business with expert advice on limited companies, reporting requirements, and corporate governance.

They can help you with registering a new company, registered office services, full Company Secretary services, and much more.

Visit 1st Formations